Categories
Eco-philo-pol

Rhys writes a nice critique of my essay

Rhys has written a long response to my essay about the free market economy, presumably from his room at the Sheraton Imperial in Kuala Lumpur. I think it’s a really great read. He even reveals the names of the "intelligent people" at university I used to have debates with. It seems that Rhys and I are more or less in the same ball court, and playing on the same team for the most part, except that we might argue about what the team’s name is. I’d just like to say a few things in my defence.

First, whilst it’s true that my economic views may have shifted back towards the "right" (the Political Compass certainly suggests this), this does not necessarily equate to a shift in political allegiance from the traditional "left" parties to the Liberals. I think this point is most clearly demonstrated by using British politics as an example. In Britain, the Labour party is traditionally classified as left, but under Tony Blair the party has moved in a decidedly Thatcherite direction. This is more or less what Rhys was getting at when speaking about shades of grey and when he says we’re all in the middle. I don’t think my essay said that the current ALP are advocates of big left government, and Rhys perhaps needn’t have jumped to the ALP’s defence quite so swiftly. Indeed, I’m not even saying that the Liberals are a good exponent of "small" government. Far from it. I totally, one hundred percent agree with Rhys when he questions the Liberals’ commitment to free trade. And yes, it was the Hawke/Keating government that made by far the largest steps in the direction of free trade. It was also the Hawke/Keating government that moved us away from an unruly and uncompetitive system of awards to a much better enterprise bargaining system, though I don’t think that goes quite far enough. The Liberals are set to reform industrial relations even further. So my article was definitely not about Liberal versus Labor, but rather about economic philosophies in general. Anyway Rhys, you can rest assurred that the Liberals have certainly not captured my vote!

Second are the notions of "big" and "small" government. I agree that these terms can sometimes be a bit vague, but I think they are used fairly consistently in the media and literature and have pretty well understood meanings attached to them. I concede that I could have this wrong, and that not everybody understands the same thing by these terms, so here’s what I mean. Big government is one which taxes highly, subsidises heavily, often intervenes and implements generous welfare schemes. Small government is one that taxes minimally, subsidises rarely (if ever), never or only occasionally intervenes, and believes that overly generous welfare schemes serve to harm society in the long term. Rhys and others might argue that I’ve still used relative terms here such as "highly", "heavily" and so forth. That’s true. But at any given time and place, these terms are resolved by comparing the different policies on offer. Other than this, my only recourse here, I fear, is to wave my hands and say it might be more meaningful to look at the reasons for setting taxation rates at a particular level. That is, what will the tax dollars actually be spent on? Maybe some people might have something further to add here (or not).

Finally, like I said in my original post, I’ve decided nothing. One thing is definite, and that is whatever my point of view on economics is, it certainly will not translate into a vote for any particular political party at the next election. Besides, I figure that being a paying member of a certain "far left" party (whose members would probably hate me now if they read my essay) obliges me to vote for them in the next election. I can live quite comfortably with this seeming contradiction for now. Hopefully I’ll have ample time in the future to resolve this issue.

By ricky

Husband, dad, R&D manager and resident Lean Startup evangelist. I work at NICTA.

5 replies on “Rhys writes a nice critique of my essay”

You need to get your message delivered and once delivered
it needs to be read. Bulk email marketing is a really
powerful and efficient marketing tool that should be a necessary part of anyy marketing plan for any corporation or
organization. This definitely is aas simple as itt sounds,
as there are countless people on the internet who might be looking for the exact product or service that you are selling.
There are many ways to advertise a product or service over the internet.
And then when you actually doo mae them an offer or ask that they purchase yopur book, you’ll
have a much easier time getting your list to opoen their wallets.

WOW.Nice read here. Toenail Fungus will be a sour fruits of the Indonesian woods known to as Garcinia
gummi-gutta. The fruits is usually of a rugby golf golf ball dimension and may possess a eco-friendly or soft
yellow color. The Toenail Fungus advantages may consist of
improved defenses levels, elevated rate of metabolism, lower
cholesterol amounts, fat obstruction, and fat reduction of
program. The herb recently obtained large recognition expected to the press coverage provided to Toenail Fungus for pounds loss attributes.
Also though there is available unquestionably no scientific
evidence to its excess weight loss home still several perception that the Hydroxycitric acidity
which composes it’s some main impact over the citrate lyase, which will be a great enzyme which changes the carbohydrate food and protein in to junk acids, which
aren’t taken through the entire body and outcome in an boost in pounds.

Find virtually any potential problems consequently
there is no leaking or disorder. A great place to stay during a fishing vacation in Christmas Island is the Captain Cook Hotel which is named after Sir
James Cook, the first person to arrive in the island on Christmas Eve of
1777. The aircon and heating system is one of the most neglected parts of a
residential home.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *